Elisa D’Amico

Revise & Resubmit

How to read a decision letter, plan the revisions, write a response memo reviewers can follow, and push back when you need to.

With Elisa D’Amico

Download the slides (PDF) Watch on YouTube

Key takeaways

  1. PublishingAn R&R, even with major revisions, is good news and counts on a CV. A rejection after revisions still happens, mostly at the most selective journals.
  2. PublishingRead the decision letter and reports, then let them sit before you plan. The editor’s guidance always outranks the reviewers’.
  3. PublishingBuild the memo skeleton first. List every reviewer point, split up combined comments, and fold repeated points together.
  4. PublishingPlan the work by theme, across all reviewers at once. Doing the empirical changes first can inform how you reframe the rest.
  5. PublishingBreak the revision into small, concrete tasks on your calendar, such as gathering data one day and running models the next, and fill in the memo as you go.
  6. PublishingFor each point, quote the comment, put your response beneath it, and say exactly where the change is (section, page, and paragraph). Mark new text in color.
  7. PublishingReviewers often read the memo first, so make it thorough and easy to skim. Give each point a short heading, and open with a note to the editor summarizing the major changes.
  8. PublishingThank reviewers without groveling, and write as if every reviewer will read every reply, because they will.
  9. PublishingPush back briefly and with reasons when a request would change the paper’s scope or cannot be done, and offer something in return, such as a footnote or a scope condition. Never ignore a point.
  10. PublishingWhen reviewers conflict, make a judgment call, explain it, and note that you defer to the editor.
  11. BooksBook revisions work differently. The memo is shorter and organized by theme, and the press may reshape your audience and expect more engagement with competing books.
  12. PublishingDeadlines are usually soft and extensions are common, but turning revisions around quickly helps on the job market. Expect more than one round.
Read the transcript

Lightly edited from Zoom’s automatic transcript, so expect some transcription errors. Speaker labels come from Zoom, and […] marks a passage that was cut.

Elisa D’Amico Okay, I can go ahead and get started, so… In terms of… all of the things we learned throughout the PhD in getting an article, you know, in the shape that it needs to be for publication, I feel like I had no idea when I got my first R&R, this was, like, not something that they had prepared me for, I think the best way to learn, and the way I learned, and I've sort of guided, more junior colleagues of mine through this situation is by having R&Rs that you're doing together in co-authored work. So I co-authored with some faculty during my PhD in towards the end when we were getting these R&Rs, and I learned what a revision memo was, like, all of this was very new to me. And yeah, so I think I'm just gonna sort of provide the lay of the land here, and things that are good to know, again, of course, from my personal perspective, So there's always that, but I think… Yeah, I think it will… help us remember how to be mindful about how to take various forms of feedback, and things like this. I also do, like, a mini R&R with myself whenever I get a review and reject. I, like, synthesize the information quite similarly, make these checklists.

Elisa D’Amico remind myself why I am or am not doing things, just to sort of keep a log of how the paper is progressing as well. So, we're gonna talk about… How to read, you know, the decision letter, the reviewer reports, what the editor said, and how to synthesize the… all of the… Various questions and move forward. How to form the response memo, what they care about. what I mean, like, I care about as a reviewer, how to push back, mindfully, carefully, how and when, I guess, and then just more practical, logistical things about, like, timelines and concerns and getting more rounds of reviews and things like this. Alright, so first, I… obviously, most submissions are desk rejected. This is okay. Sometimes the… editor will give some feedback as well, that… but it's normally quite minor on a… upon a desk reject, that you can kind of work with. But if you've got an R&R, you are far past this. It's a very, very good sign. This is excellent to have on your CV if you're going on the job market.

Elisa D’Amico even if you get major revisions, I often get major revisions personally. It's still good news, it still means there's some promise, it still means that, you know, even if it ends up not getting accepted, that the… you have excellent feedback that is gonna, like, really help develop the paper quite a bit. Again, it's not a promise. There are situations, especially depending on the journals, where oftentimes they will reject a paper after they resubmit. And then you can appeal in this and that. this does happen at very, very, very tough journals. But in general, it's a fairly good sign. But of course, it's not a for sure, it's not 100%, just because you have an R&R. I would suggest to read the report, like, carefully, before you get right into how you're gonna tackle all of the comments. I would sit with it for a little bit and let it synthesize. You can recalibrate and center yourself with, like, the goal of the paper, what it's about, especially when reviewer feedback is conflicting.

Elisa D’Amico Before you start, sort of, formulating a plan. I think that in terms of if you're quite an early career scholar, if you can get an R&R on one of your dissertation papers before going on the job market, that's… Definitely ideal. That's definitely, definitely ideal, at least. Some people have way more, Some people are not even close to this. And so, like, it's… I mean, like, I've had job talks and fly-outs at all phases of this, so it… I mean, things, of course, are changing, but this is a decent benchmark. Okay. So, of course, the editor always outranks the reviewers when there is Feedback, and the editor should tell you if your reviewers conflict or if there's just a lot of reviews in general, the editor will normally tell you, like, what they… what direction they think you should take, and that's really helpful when they do, and you always follow the guideline of the editor. I would say… I will talk about pushing back against the some of the, feedback or suggestions as well. I would never do this with the editor, for example. And so… the… let's see what else? The… so the way… this isn't universal, but I always write… my own… section of the memo to the editor at the very top, and in this section, I also sometimes ask them, like.

Elisa D’Amico If they didn't tell me, like, these two reviews differ, we went with this. We're happy to add this, like, let us know, type of a thing. I try not to do this too much, but if there's something that is, like, a really, like, you know, like, a point of disagreement, this is fine. Yeah, so if the editor doesn't really, like, push on certain reviews. You can maybe feel more comfortable pushing back against those. We can talk a little bit more about this later on. So… this tension about when the reviewers are disagreeing, and this happens a lot. Oftentimes, you can sort of, like, you can do what you can with it, you can make one thing a footnote while, like, tightening up another thing. It is normally fairly doable, and as I said, the editor should be telling you who to follow, and if they don't, you can ask them.

Elisa D’Amico But I… I mean, maybe… I wouldn't email them, editors are so busy. I would, as I said, I think on the previous slide, make the call yourself, like, have this judgment call, and then do this note to the editor at the top. You can always split it up. You can do exactly what they asked, but then, yes, take it out as in you put it in the appendix. like… we cut the discussion in general, but kept the depth on just these interesting points. We pulled it out of the figures, because one reviewer thought that was confusing, or we relegated it to an appendix, a footnote, things like this. yeah, are a bit of judgment calls, and there's no real clear answer here. And in general, with sorting out the comments, there's stuff you must do, stuff you can push back on. I've spoken of this. Of course, once again, anything that the editor doubles down on is something you want to absolutely do, to the best of your ability. If there's a lot of overlap amongst the reviewers, that's clearly a sign that that needs to go in the paper. If it's reasonable, like, sometimes I just go through and add all of the citations that they request, or the footnotes that they request, or clarifications. I can… I often do, like, a big pass on that, and then you're left with some of the bigger stuff to work through.

Elisa D’Amico you can always push back if there's contradictions. This happens a lot. Sometimes one of the reviewers really does have a different idea of how the paper should go, and you do find yourself pushing back on them a lot. Sometimes this happens because they want to see… they're more interested in a version of this paper, or, like, a paper that isn't quite… like, what the… what your paper is, like, oftentimes they will be like, well, I would like to see blah blah blah blah blah. Which… you're often like, I would also like to see that, maybe you write it, I'll write it, we can write it together, you know? Like, it's… it's hard to… sometimes a reviewer will, like, take a piece of it and run with it a little bit. And so… in those cases, you can be like, this is an interesting area for future research that I, like, built out a lot more in my conclusions.

Elisa D’Amico And yeah, you don't wanna necessarily… I mean, like, you… you're certainly not gonna lie, like, if they ask for robustness checks. you're gonna do them, even if they push back against, like, how clean things looked before, you're just gonna be… you're just gonna hedge a little bit more, and that's fine. But if they're more interested in this other theoretical framing, or this other very, very specific contribution. And the editors, the other reviewers, don't push you in this direction, and it would make major changes to the paper and, like, make the argument more confusing, like, you can push back against that. Like, as in, you're like, I… agree that this is a very good point. I think that… The scope of this particular paper doesn't really touch that, but it's interesting if we were to tweak these various parts or focus more on this or that, then that would be a big part of the story, and that's something that Like, we now caveat, or, like, raise in the scope conditions, something like that is perfectly fine.

Elisa D’Amico Cause you want… What happens sometimes with especially major R&Rs, is that the paper ends up kind of not feeling like the paper that you originally submitted, because it has undergone so much surgery from all of these different angles, but you still want it to maintain its continuity and its coherence, and oftentimes you do have to push back certain reviewers in order to retain that coherence. Major versus minor revisions… minor revisions are much more promising. You will… That looks a lot more like a potential acceptance. Major revisions. can be almost, like, as difficult or harder than writing the paper the first time itself, but it's also a testament as to why we send the paper out and we don't make it, necessarily, like, don't worry about it being the most perfected, polished thing in the world, because you're gonna get reviewers, and the reviewers are gonna want you to make changes, and that's gonna be work. So you can only sort of, like.

Elisa D’Amico Continue tweaking it here and there, and polishing it so much, because your reviewers will have requests for you, and you will be following your reviewers, rather than the… your intuition are the last people that have seen your paper, because that's who we need to answer to. And then the… sometimes I do the… I've seen major revisions, like, that I was a reviewer for, where I was, like. Oh, like, I… it's a very marginal… like, it was, like, nearly a reject, but I was like, you know what, it's technically possible. if you use this data, if you do all of these things for you to tell this story, I was very, very detailed, but, like, in my mind, I was like, I'm saying… I'm giving it a major revision because it's possible, but in reality, like, I'm not so sure that… it shouldn't be a reject. But they delivered, and it ended up being a really good paper. Like, they really, really delivered. They took all these comments on board. They… Like, were very clear, like, they… responded to every single point, like, it was really, really, really well done, and I'm glad that I gave that a major revision instead of a reject, because it did have the potential, but they really underwent a lot in their revisions to, like, make it what it is now. That is… that it's published, and… that's okay, like, that's fine, it's still published now, you know, and it looks really good. So, yeah, it can be some very, very, very big things.

Elisa D’Amico Minor revisions are… like, normally quite doable. Sometimes it's adding more literature, tweaking the figures, some… the editor might ask you for some formatting stuff at this phase. It's normally achievable to do, like, you can… I mean, this is… like, from my point of view, but you can normally turn around a minor revision paper in about a week. For the major revision papers, those things, it can take a really, really long time. And… Along these lines, like. don't worry so much about the formatting, the citation style, things like this, especially even when submitting to the journal in the first place, because that's not going to be the reason why a paper gets, like, rejected or not. Like, there… like, these can be some, like, nitpicky things, but it's something that you'll deal with in proofs later on down the road.

Elisa D’Amico So, the way that I personally plan my revisions. So… I try to sit with it for a little bit, but even before that, I normally try to organize them. So I make this skeleton of my revision memo, where I list every single point that every single reviewer made. Every single point, I disaggregate it, and I kind of clean it up. You know, if they, like, double down on a point, I'll move it back to the original point. And so I make this skeleton. I have, like, a very clear, which I might show later, a very clear format as to, like, what my revision memos end up looking like. And… I have, like, an overleaf, like, my, like, own personal template that I always use that has, like, the quoted reviewer comment, indented, like, block quote of my response, and then that says response, and then underneath that it says, changes made, and that is, like, me pointing to the location of the changes that were made that I just talked about in the response. And so this is what I do for every single paper, and so I like to organize all of the comments into that right away.

Elisa D’Amico Just to, like, get the lay of the land, read everything very carefully, and then, like… once I'm looking at it, and I can start thinking about what I need to, like, tick, tick, tick, check off, that's when I can sort of start thinking about what like, you know, what is contradicting each other, what is overlapping? What should I push back with? I wait a little bit, and then I make my plan. lumping the points into categories, so… what I do, like I said, is first I do normally a big pass of, like, smaller things, minor things, very, like, achievable little things. Sometimes I even disaggregate The… within each reviewer's point-by-point, comments, I will have, like, all of their big comments, and then I'll have, like, a subheading that's, like, minor points, and then it's just, like, the littler things, like, added this citation here, da-da-da-da-da, incorporated this, adjusted the way I worded this language, that was slightly inaccurate, that sort of thing.

Elisa D’Amico And then when you're organizing this for yourselves. you should be lumping in related stuff so that you can do it together. I… I mean, this is just a suggestion. I guess it's a matter of preference, but I don't really do, like, one reviewer at a time. I do all of the theoretical reframing, literature, and scope stuff first. And then I'll do the empirics. Actually, I normally do the empirical changes first, in case that then informs some of the tweaks that need to happen in the first part. So I do all the empirical robustness stuff, things like that. Then I go back and do all the scope framing, then I will, like, build out the discussion with these examples, policy implications that they asked for, things like this. So I… And if it's a very big revision, sometimes one of my days that I plan to work on it, I'm just telling myself to get together all of the data and start writing the R script for the, additional robustness checks that I'm about to do. Like, that's all I do in that day. And then I'll have a day where I run it, and then I'll have a day where I then, like.

Elisa D’Amico Analyze it, like, enter it back in, And I… yeah, and I often fill out the memo kind of as I go, along these bigger categories. I guess you could do it point by point, or reviewer by reviewer. Again, I wouldn't recommend that, because maybe you make all of these changes that The first reviewer suggested, and then you get to the third reviewer, and there's contradictions, and then you have nothing already, like, nothing that you aren't pushing back on on Reviewer 3, and then you're like, oh shoot, they're… I can't push back on everything, but I already, like, pretty much did what Reviewer 1 wanted, whereas if you did them all together, you could think more carefully about what you're doing. when, and who you're appeasing when. Yes, so same with the manageable chunks scheduling. I don't ever, ever, ever just put work on my R&R, like, on my calendar for that day, ever. I split it up into, like, a million like, chewable pieces, like… attainable pieces that are very, very small, and I'm gonna do that that day, right? Like, one day, get the data. Next day, write the script. Third day, run the models. Fourth day, add them to the appendix. You know, like, like this sort of a thing. And I will maybe spread it out.

Elisa D’Amico do it, like, one afternoon a week or something. I definitely allow myself the time to… and then if I, you know, if I get done with it, I can, like, keep going and moving on and adjust my calendar and my, like, schedule and stuff, but… just to ensure that, you know, if you get results that aren't the way you expected, it gives you, like, all of this buffer time and, like, stages in order to, like, kick the can down the road without it becoming this, like, big, unmanageable thing, that you have to do, and give you time to make some more thoughtful adjustments based on things that Perhaps don't work out how you planned, and things like that, so… working through it. Like I said, I fill in the memo as I go, so I do all the models, and then I'll respond to all of the empirical model comments. In the response memo, this is a great idea, thank you so much. I… was unaware of this data, but it absolutely should be included. You're very right, this was an oversight about, this model specification, like… I've done all of these robustness checks and more. All of these things go in after the empirical part is done. And then for me, that's that whole chunk done. I don't have to worry about that again. And then that's, like.

Elisa D’Amico say it takes me 4 weeks to do that, a month to do that, then that's my planning. That's, like, month number one has empirics done, but, like, in the days I plan to do them, it's super achievable, and I'm always filling out the memo as I go. This is also why I use Overleaf, I can save every version along the way quite nicely. And then, at the end, I go back through and read the paper cover to cover, I go back through and read the memo cover to cover. Sometimes there's stuff that you're like, oh, wait, I think that's what this reviewer was saying. I slightly misunderstood. And you do some tweaks, you want to make sure it's coherent. You want to make sure that you're not favoring one reviewer so much over the other reviewer, more or less.

Elisa D’Amico And that your language was careful when you were responding to the mean reviewer. And then also, at the very end, I told you that I have the comment, the response, and then below that, the, what was changed, and in the what was changed. part, I will be, like, section 3.1, page 9, paragraph 3, like, very specifically. And I also do my tracked… I mean, like, Overleaf doesn't really do tracked changes the same way that, like, Microsoft Word does, for example. But I personally will, like, make all of my changes in red, so that… like, the reviewer can see. So they'll go to that paragraph, they'll see the red, they'll know. Yeah, and then because I've done all these passes and adjusts, like, adjustments, I just write the response itself as I go, and then I go back and do the locations of the changes at the end, because it will change, right?

Elisa D’Amico As you write more. So… This actually, I can't speak for all reviewers, but personally, I always read the memo first to see what they said they did and what they pushed back on, And also get a sense of what the other reviewers pushed on, too. And this is helpful so that, you know, I can know Like, I'm not gonna double down on something I wanted to see if, in the scheme of things, it really… was not a unanimous thing, it, like, made it a little bit harder for the reviewers to keep their continuity, like, so that's why I, like, read the memo first, so that I can look at how everybody's questions were answered, what the other reviewers said at all, and whether they answered them. And then I go back into the paper and, like, just, like, look at the stuff that I really, really, really cared about, depending on how… major the revisions were. And so… like, I would not skimp… I would not skimp on making the memo thorough. Like, of course, you want the paper to be very good if you were to read it just cover to cover. Like, you want it to be quite polished, but that might not fully be what the reviewers do, especially depending on like, it might be major revisions, because two reviewers thought it was major revisions. One might have thought it was, like, ready to go. Like, you… like, we want to read, like, the memo. The memo is very important.

Elisa D’Amico And, you know, depending on reviewers' time, bandwidth, whatever, if it seems like you didn't really answer their questions in the memo, like, they might be less keen to go and read the whole paper, like, front to back, if it wasn't clear, or you didn't direct them, push them in the right direction. So definitely be really good about your responses in the memo, make it easy for the reviewer to find what they asked for, and of what exactly you said and where you said it. I mean, sometimes revision memos are very, very long, and that can be a lot to deal with, but it's really good for the reviewers to be able to, like, easily identify the changes that were made. Make it skimmable in this very sense, right? So that you can just, like. go through. I was reviewer 2, apparently, I see. I'm gonna go see the stuff that I knew was a really big deal to me, I'm gonna read all of that. I'm gonna check in the paper, because they told me to look at the page, like, it's… it's easy, right?

Elisa D’Amico Ways to organize the revision memo vary, and it also kind of depends on the round of revisions itself. So what I've kind of been describing is this one that I do more frequently, which is, like. Point by point. Reviewer 1, point, point, point, point. Reviewer 2, point, point, point. And sometimes I organize thematically within them. But more or less, I keep it, like, reviewer by reviewer. And I do that so that each reviewer can easily see what they wanted, and, and, like. whether their specific requests were met. It, like, doesn't look like you, like, skipped any of, like, what they said in favor of, like, more higher-level stuff or other reviewers. there is a lot of repetition in these, I would say, and sometimes when I'm, like, on Reviewer 3, and I… they have the exact same comment. I will be like, see, please see response to .1… 0.6, because they asked the same thing.

Elisa D’Amico So this can happen, too, to avoid some repetition, or say a sentence, and then push them to that other reference. And then the other way is to go by issue. So, like, they wanted me to… like, do this big thing. So reviewers 1, 2, and 3 all wanted me to do this. And then thank you for your comments to reviewers 2 and 1 that wanted me to do this. And you can do it like that, and that's more coherent, concise. An editor probably would like that better, to be fair. And so, like, this is an option as well, and this can work. maybe a little bit nicer if it is more of a minor revisions thing. There's reasons to use both. I prefer the former, just to… as a commitment mechanism to myself, and then you can also make the former that way, in order to, like, keep yourself accountable and make sure you did everything, and then, like, organize it after the fact into this more, like, thematic version if you want. Again, I've used both I prefer the former. And as I also said, you can always do the point-by-point, just to make sure you check all your boxes and then collapse it later.

Elisa D’Amico Going the other ways. difficult, because then, like, at some point, you will have to go to every reviewer's, like, line-by-line comment anyway, if you want to, like, re-extract it. But you can use the thematic, big, high-level stuff anyway to… like, what I do is I'll write it out in this way, in this, like, split-apart way, but then I will get a sense, and my plan for how I do the revisions will be organized by category rather than reviewer, if that makes sense. you can do a summary of the changes made. Sometimes people do it in the beginning, sometimes people do it in the beginning and the end. Most of the time, they do it at the beginning. Like, what I do is in my, I almost always sort of do it. Most of the time, it's built into my, like, note to the editor at the top of the memo, and this is where I will be, like.

Elisa D’Amico These reviewers, these reviews were very valuable. these are a handful of the major changes that I made. That was, like, unanimous across all reviewers, that… Seriously improved the paper, right? So, that's what I normally do. It doesn't have to be that comprehensive. Sometimes it's nice if you do this point-by-point version to do, like, a summary. That helps get it more thematic. Yeah, so the first version, I had this paper, where, it was, like, lumped into 14 high-level issues, and then you always do some sort of disaggregated minor points at the end. But this would be, like, these reviewers both want it, or thank you to this reviewer, but it was, like, a really big ask. And then… the second time we did, like, reviewer by reviewer, also, just because there were so few points that we were like, okay, you wanted this check, you wanted this check, you wanted this check, and it's easier, this… it can be easier and, like, cleaner this way.

Elisa D’Amico I've done it this way, it's not how I really do it anymore. Also, resubmitting a cover letter. Sometimes you resubmit a cover letter with the… review. I only really do this if I need to, like, really flag something to the editors, like, more clearly, like, the title has changed entirely, so this is manuscript blah blah blah, I normally don't. Anything that I would normally say in a cover letter, I just put in my note to the editor at the top, but this is what we did with our former paper. One of my first R&Rs, actually. And then… I, like I said, I use a very precise Overleaf template. I have, like, a title page, a very clear hyperlinked table of contents that the reviewers can easily navigate, summary of the major revisions at the top, sort of whatever, along with the editors. Like I said, these points 2 and 3 here, I kind of merge into one, so I do sort of, like, summary editor thing at the top, and then I go into, like, my… subheadings where I'm like, reviewer 1 has 1.1, Reviewer 2 has 2.1, 2.2, and so on.

Elisa D’Amico And so… I also will have, like I said, I do put in quotes the comments they made. If they blabber on in the middle, I'll do, like, the little dot dot dot ellipses, and then, like, finish with the point. But… whenever I do that, I do, like, a short, like, I don't know, few… word heading, or, like, maybe one sentence, short headings, of what it was. Like, on the point where they asked me to talk More about… or, like, deeper discussion of… causal pathway about the resources, whatever it is. Like, I will just, like, put a little heading there so that I remember what it is, and reviewers can get their memories jogged by what their, like, higher level points were, and also to indicate that this is how you understood it, especially if there's, like, a lack of clarity between the reviewers What they thought they were asking, and what you thought they were asking as well.

Elisa D’Amico Okay, apologies for that. So… The formatting, that works. for me, and I've kind of talked about this along the way. is that I put this, like, quote, Like, quote, like, in quotations as the sort of high-level subheading after the title. Verbatim from what they said, and then under that, I do the block quotes. that, like, sort of indent in and show the response itself, and then under that, I then have where the changes were made. highlighting what you changed so they can find that this is, like, the sort of, like, tracked revisions, like, me putting everything in red and overleaf. I also… for myself, when I'm going through revisions, I… like, highlights with, like, I don't know, highlight… highlighter, like the color book, overleaf… function. all of the stuff that I haven't done yet. So every single reviewer, like, heading will be highlighted yellow.

Elisa D’Amico Before I've started, and then as I start filling out the responses, I unhighlight, if that makes sense. And this is just a way of me to keep track of what I'm doing. I always keep that little changes made art highlighted until the very end, because I don't change that until the end. And then… Yeah, you can group by… The severity, As well, as we've said on the last few slides. So naming it what we said already. So this is the… And a couple of examples of memos that I've, created over time. Let's see which ones are these. So, these ones are both sort of point-by-point within reviewers, but you can see, in terms of, like, severity. On the left here, I'm sort of doing, like, strictly point-by-point, and I even have… the editor had a lot of suggestions here, too, so I even have editor point-by-point. But on the right here, it is more, like, I, like, subset it within the reviewer, so… I have major theoretical stuff, and then I have data stuff, and then I have… method stuff, and then I have minor points, and I'll do that, like, within each reviewer.

Elisa D’Amico So that they can see, like, how I itemize… in an itemized way, how I tackled everything, like, within these broader categories, because sometimes the feedback is kind of fragmented, where they'll, like, be back in the empirics, they'll talk about the theory again, and things like that. This is the format of what it looks like. So you can see that I have… The comments here, from, like, this is my reviewer one, and this is how I answer it, and oftentimes, you do, I mean, sometimes on every single point, but I try not to do it on every single point, but, like, you do a bit of a thank you, point well taken, we appreciate the suggestion, thank you for the suggestion on literature, da-da-da-da. There's a lot of the thank you, but then you can see here that I subset the response, and then the changes made come below. So this is what I'm talking about in terms of the format. And then my block is in full. Like, this is me very, in a very comprehensive way, answering the comment.

Elisa D’Amico numbered and named. As you can see, like, I have comment one random forest interpretation. I was like… the way I was alluding to it was, like. almost, like, overfitting the model a little bit, rather than just more of a robustness thing. And so, yeah, you can kind of see this here, and I keep this format no matter what, every time. Yeah, we've been talking about this marked-up thing, so… a lot of journals want to see your polished, clean version and your marked-up version, and I don't know why LaTeX has such a hard time with these, like, tracked changes, I guess. Like, there's ways of doing it, maybe if you look in your history. If you hadn't done it along the way. But just now, to be prudent, when I go along, every new thing I do, I put in this color red function. And then, of course, I think there's ways of doing this in Microsoft Word.

Elisa D’Amico Yeah. So marked up file shows exactly what you did, but if the reviewer or the editor wants, like, a clean read, or to send it to a new reviewer, maybe, or whatever, it depends, they like a polished version, too. And they also like your raw version, so if you do use LaTeX, Sometimes they ask for it when you submit the second like, sometimes, like, they ask for it right away, but sometimes you can get away with the PDF, but then they'll ask you for the raw LaTeX files when you submit your sec- your first revision, because then it's closer to, like, the editing acceptance proof phase, so they want to have the stuff there so it can move along quickly. So… Yes, the marked up… File shows how many… how much… how much of the changes you made, right? And, like, how much is new text.

Elisa D’Amico But it's kind of a pain, maybe easier in Microsoft Word, I'm not sure. Books are different. I'm just gonna briefly mention this here. The way that I handled my book revisions and my book… proposal revisions were really interesting, and the way that I'm handling the revision… er, not revisions, even, but, like. yeah, reviewer comments, suggestions that I'm working on now that I have my contract. It's just a very different… like, there's a lot of things that are the same in terms of their organization, how you go about it. Obviously, you don't have to push back in the same way, because it's probably not going to go to these same reviewers. that did, like, the proposal, the initial phase. Maybe it does, I don't know, but, the book is gonna take on, like, a life of its own along the way, and there's gonna be so much that they haven't yet seen. So so much of it will be brand new. Like.

Elisa D’Amico I think that… you will have these reader reports. I put 4 here, this is my experience, this may be abnorm, I don't know. and honestly, with reviewers as well, like, there's often times in, like, social sciences 2 or 3, but I've had, like, science articles that they had, like, five, six reviewers, something like that. And there will be a lot more from the editor up front with the book revisions that is formatting related, because books are so different, you know? footnote, endnote stuff, in-text citations, like, very specific, like, word counts or paragraph sizes even, like, preferences about the Oxford comma. There is a lot more, so I actually do look at the formatting more. Or I did it for the book because I wanna… Like, have the path of least resistance for myself, and, like, make it easier for, like, the later version of myself.

Elisa D’Amico So there is some more, structural stuff. And then, also, something that's a big difference about the book is the audience. So, maybe I originally… like, I… for my book, for example, I originally wanted to frame it towards a wider audience, and they suggested that I frame it more towards, like, graduate students. experts this sort of audience, and that also changes many things about how I write, the language I use, how much I explain different things. Like, it makes a very big difference. They want to see more engagement with, like. Competing Works, other major books as well. A state of the, like, literature, almost, in a way that… isn't quite the way we think about it in, like, the one-off journal article form. I made revisions to… or I… I don't know, so I had two rounds of reviews, one with Oxford University Press, the second with… okay, and the second with Cambridge University Press. I took the Oxford University Press reviews, and then in my… proposal that I then sent to Cambridge, I… told them all of the reviews I previously had, and the stuff I wanted to change. And then, I… that one out, along with some chapters for review, and then I edited that report again with this additional batch of reviews, like my proposal, my prospectus, then for the syndicate to decide on whether they were going to give me a contract or not, so I was just… doing this revision memo sort of thing, like, the revision memo wasn't the same, it was just, like, baked into my proposal, and it was much more concise, high-level, streamlined.

Elisa D’Amico Super different than how I did it with the papers, which is, like, literally line by line, right? And then, of course, like, the review process and the work process and everything is… is different with the books. I was just gonna… So there's… there's also a timeline situation. I think we might be getting down to a couple slides. Otherwise, if there's questions, So, like, yeah, my book memo was by theme. Like, this was… I guess I just said this, but this was… like, part of it is, like, listen, I know that, like, this was formerly a dissertation, and there's a lot that I need to do, to get into book shape, including XYZ. And then, competing works, like, I know I need to engage with all this more, I have this higher level theory thing, And, yeah, like I said about the audience, when you see a lot of overlap amongst the reviewers, again, of course, this is going to be one of these higher level themes that you want to make sure you're doing. Yeah. So, mine was by theme, also because the… syndicate, or the editors, like, these people haven't… we're not the original reviewers, and they are the deciders, so it's a little bit different in that way. So a cover letter, this is kind of, like, another logistical thing, but kind of more going back to the papers, but also was kind of baked into the book prospectus that I sent off as well. But in general, for the… actual… R&R. If you do submit a new cover letter, and there's different reasons why you might or might not do this, right? But you're gonna say.

Elisa D’Amico something super short, you're not gonna regurgitate the memo, you're gonna be like, what changed? At what level? of theory, what's your evidence, what's the framing? It's gonna be, like, these high-level changes as well. Again, I normally just incorporate this in the letter to the editors. Some people's preferences is to always, Included a new cover letter as well. And then major structural things, like I said, are gonna have to be added in there, too. So, it's kind of awkward to write the revision memo itself, because, as I said, like, you don't want to grovel, you don't want to beg the reviewers to try to believe you. You want to, like, have this confidence, and this is why I also encourage this pushing back, because it reminds the reviewers that, like, this is your paper, you are the expert, you're not, like, there to serve their absolute every whim, because, like, reviewers can be quite fickle.

Elisa D’Amico But you want to be grateful for all of the feedback, which we are, right? So, I will be, like. thank you very much for this point, or point well taken. Like, it's just respectful to the work that they put in, the service to the discipline, that sort of thing. like I said, I try to, like, embed the… This was an excellent suggestion, thank you so much, I really appreciate this point. Like, at least every few reviews, I feel like doing it in every single comment is a little bit overdone, and honestly, not every single comment is an excellent point, and I'm not grateful for every single comment. I mean, I am, but, Yeah, you don't want it to seem, like, too cheeky, or of course not sarcastic. You want to seem… confident, polite, like, you're engaging, like, as if you were talking to a colleague, or, like, somebody on your panel that had, like, some really, like, excellent, like, feedback, like, engaging in this, like, way.

Elisa D’Amico Assuming that, also, that everybody will read what you said to everybody else. this is also very important, because, like, you don't want to be like, oh, thank you so much, Reviewer 1, you are the best, you loved my paper, thank you, this was so good, I made all these changes. Like, you don't want to seem that way when Reviewer 2 reads Reviewer 1, and they're like, oh, I see, like, cool, like. They didn't do any of these changes they hated. like, my suggestions, but they, like, really liked this other review. Like, you don't want to seem that way. You want to be consistent, you want to be professional. You're grateful even if you… it's not in the scope, or you've chosen not to maybe adjust the scope based on other feedback or other changes that developed as you did your revisions. That's fine. And then… Yeah, what to do when reviewers disagree. So… This is just, again, a little bit about the tone and the language, like.

Elisa D’Amico You always agree with the reviewer for raising the point itself, but then you can caveat, then you can, like. narrow the scope, right? So, like, this distinction is right, like, I failed to… like, clarify this, we totally accept it, but now we say in the text that it's only a case about this, rather than maybe they wanted me to tell, like, a more complete story about a mechanism about this other part, but that's not really what we do. You… even if you don't really integrate what they wanted in full, like, try to throw it a bone. if you've, like, gone ahead with something else, I said this earlier, like, if you are going with an… if there was some pushback, you should still, like, add in a footnote that gives a caveat or something, like… like… like I said, throw the… throw the reviewer a bone, if you can.

Elisa D’Amico there's obvious reasons to not do what some reviewers want, like, literally the data doesn't exist. That's the next paper, this is the jumping off point for that thing you're curious about. It's a little bit trickier when Like, one reviewer wants you to… take half the paper and put that in a different paper, and the other doesn't. Like, that can be a little hard when… one wants you to condense more, but stuff like that is more gonna be, like, follow on the editor to decide anyway. I will sometimes say, in the response, I will be like, this… Was that odds with the point that we got from another reviewer? see response to, comment, blah blah blah. However. we decided to go along those lines, but we are deferring to… I'll say this in my response to the comment for the reviewer that I didn't go with. We are deferring to the editor if they think that, because these were conflicting views, that this is the path that we should take, and then I'll put that up top in the editor, like, brief editor comments. But normally your intuition is right. Like, you have reasons for going with the one thing over the other, for continuity reasons, for coherence, and it probably fits overall with the paper better, and I've never once I don't think had an editor say, oh, like, you raised this point to me that you were deferring to me, I think you should have done the other thing. That's never happened to me. But it's good to just, like, have in there anyway. Because then it also, like, mollifies the… reviewer a little bit, like, we're like, okay, fine, like, well, if the editor thinks, so then they'll let them know.

Elisa D’Amico Yeah. don't ever ignore a point, because it might be the point that annoyed the reviewer the most. Like, I get this a lot sometimes with… even at, like, workshops, if we're all discussing papers, I'll be, like, reviewing the feedback, I'll take some of the points, like. as if they were, like, the bigger points, and then the colleague will be like, no, no, no, it was this other thing that, like, it's really bothering me. And I'm like, oh. So you don't actually always know what the part… like, I actually had a… I had a paper that… was a review and reject. I submitted it to a different journal, and I made a ton of changes. I made a ton of changes. And I submitted it to a different journal. And then the… I got 2 out of 3 of the same reviewers from the previous versions, and I had made a ton of changes, but they review and rejected again. They were like, I see that the author made a lot of changes since the last time I saw this, however, like, it was this other thing I really cared about, and I was like, oh!

Elisa D’Amico But that's okay, too. Like, but that's why you… I mean, you do want to push back. Like, these are review and rejects, so I didn't get to do the revision memo, or anything to the actual editors. I only did a revision memo, kind of, with myself, or to the reviewers. I did it with myself, so it's not like they knew… how much I, like, you know, did, like, decide what to do where, like, if I were to be able to be like, I looked for this, the data didn't exist, I'm sorry, like, but therefore I blah blah blah, maybe they would have felt differently and less ignored. But this has sort of happened to me. I've actually seen this, like, the reviewer misunderstands this point. Honestly, I might have done this once or twice, but I… you really try not to do that. Like, they read what you wrote, so if they misunderstood, you were probably unclear. Or, if you think you were clear, reading it back, make it clear.

Elisa D’Amico Arguing for a paragraph when changing one's sentence would do like that. can be kind of annoying, like, I would say… like… when I'm pushing back, it's quite concise. Like, I'm, like, thankful, I say I've added a scope condition here, but you don't have to be, like. Like, no, and this is why it's not in the paper, like, this is why it's not… worth it here, this is why, like, and you didn't really understand how I was really talking about this. Like, you, like, I, like, you, I never argue, argue, argue in the revision memo. Like, just be like, that's not really what this paper ended up taking for blah blah blah reasons, done. you don't want to have… like, and this is, like, not something that I've really come across yet in the type of work that I do, but there's some, like, it's starting to get to the point where I'm having a lot of the same reviewers, and… like… I know that they like to see things a certain way. I'm, like, kind of finding evidence of something else.

Elisa D’Amico I know they're my reviewers, I know they're gonna see this, and they're gonna kind of want to push the other way, like, I can't… I'm not in the business of, like, not wanting my papers published, and I'm also not in the business of saying things that I'm not actually finding, because there's normally some truths to… both sides of the coin, I'm not gonna, like, die on a hill and lose the publication opportunity. As long as it's good research and, like. the… both sides of these points can fit nicely into the paper and coherently, you know? Timelines, so… I really shouldn't say this, but deadlines are normally soft. When I was on the job market, I was trying to turn around every single revision, even major ones, within, like, 2 or 3 weeks. So that I could get publications, you know? And, like, I actually recommend kind of doing that. I mean, not if it's gonna be at the expense of the quality of the revision.

Elisa D’Amico But… like, now that I'm an assistant professor, I feel a little bit differently, where I feel like the… like, like, I would. Like, there was a point in time where I would never ask. Like, I would tell my co-authors, like, don't you dare make me ask for an extension on this revision. And, like, I've, like, I've certainly, like, evolved beyond that, because now people are busy, they have lives, like… if things take a while, like, I have a solo… like, if I had a younger colleague that needed publications out, I would try to turn it around quickly, too. But, like, I have a solo-authored paper right now that is major revisions, and I'm working on this, like, 2 days a month. They gave me 6 months, I'm working on it, like, 2 days a month. Because I am so incredibly busy. And I'm fine with that now. I'm like, how long? You said 6 months? I will take the full 6 months.

Elisa D’Amico So it's fine, and then you can ask for these extensions, right? In fact, this is kind of common to ask for these extensions. I mean, common definitely if you are the reviewer. reviewers are often, like, not meeting deadlines, but if you're the author, you want to meet your deadlines, if you can. But they normally will soften extensions. I mean, like, sometimes like, for the science journals, I remember my co-author and I didn't realize they wanted it turned around in, like, 2 weeks or something, and we were both at a conference or something, we couldn't work on it yet, and then we saw, and we were like, oh my gosh, we asked for an extension then, right? always expect another round of revisions. Well, I guess I'm personally speaking, because so many of my revisions are major revisions, but… that's okay to get more rounds. It's gonna be a lot less feedback. Sometimes it's still substantial, but the… substantial-ish, but the editor still sees a lot of promise in it. And when that happens, normally it's that, like, two of the reviewers were like, great, good to go, send it, and one of the reviewers, like, no, you still didn't do what I wanted you to do. And so you do have to do some more careful work, like.

Elisa D’Amico dealing with that, and that's fine. The editor wouldn't have given it back to you in that condition if they didn't also agree with it. So you do what you can. again, a reject after an R&R happens, but I also, like. it happens, but when that happens, it means you're shooting for really high journals, you know? And that can only be a good thing. The fact you got an R&R from there in the first place is, like, an excellent sign, and it means that it went through a round of revisions with excellent reviewers, and so it's a better paper for it. And then whatever reasons why the reject happens either after the revisions or if the editor is just, like, saying, oh wait, no, we don't want it because of this, then that's what you focus on for your revisions before you resubmit.

Elisa D’Amico So… And R&R is also always a good outcome. Like, of course, you can maybe get it rejected, but, like, search committees, like, people take an R&R on a CV quite seriously. the editor's letter is what you… and suggestions is what you want to follow entirely. Focus a lot on making your memo really, really, really strong. Of course, the paper needs to be strong, but don't skip out on the memo. And if you disagree, and when you disagree, and when reviewers disagree, whatever you're pushing back, just give reasons and throw them a bone. And then Kasia is not here, but Kasia is more used to getting minor revisions, than me, and so I was gonna say she could speak a little bit about that. I don't know if she kind of changes the point by point, or sort of lumps things together, but all of these options do exist, so thank you for viewing, and, we can take some questions.